A report by the Fiscal Responsibility Index (FRI) has shown that only two Federal Government ministries—the Ministries of Water Reicy linkages, budget comprehensiveness and transparency out of more than 1,000 existing Ministries, Departments and Agencies (MDAs) subjected to the test, an instrument for benchmarking fiscal activities across Federal Government ministries, departments and agencies
All other participating MDAs scored below the 50 per cent, according to the FRI report covering 2023–2025, publicly unveiled on Monday by the Fiscal Responsibility Commission (FRC), in collaboration with the Centre for Social Justice (CSJ).
In the report obtained by New Telegraph, seven ministries—Education, Youth Development, Works, Police Affairs, Justice, Information and National Orientation, and A for exhibiting weak alignment between their budgets and policy priorities
Policy-based budgeting requires an assessment of fiscal sustainability
“Policy-based budgeting requires an assessment of fiscal sustainability that reconciles expenditure ceilings, programme costs, and policy objectives,” the FRI report noted.
On the aspect of budget credibility and realism, the report disclosed that only eight MDAs—the Ministries of Water Reuties; Information and National Orientation; Housing and Urban Development; Power; Defence; and Regional Development—scored above the 50 per cent benchmark
“Budget credibility and realism perform two important functions: improve the government’s operational efficiency by requiring explicit trade-offs among priorities and supporting better coordination among dispersed actors; and they clarify what the government is expected to deliver in return for continued financial support.
Three factors may contribute to an unrealistic
“Three factors may contribute to an unrealistic or non-credible budget: uncertainty about future economic and fiscal conditions; principal–agent problems, where the executive cannot fully control the actions of subordinate institutions or officials; and strategic signalling, where the executive publishes commitments intended to secure the support of external stakeholders but does not fully intend or expect to implement them,” the report explained.
In his welcome remarks, the Acting Chairman of the FRC, Charles Chukwuemeka Abana, Esq., said the presentation of the report represented another significant mile
1,000 Being the minimum number of MDAs in the country
stone in the Commission’s efforts to deepen the institutionalisation of fiscal responsibility principles across the Federal Government.
He described the exercise as an opportunity
He described the exercise as an opportunity to collectively reflect on the performance of ministries, departments and agencies in implementing statutory public financial management requirements and to identify areas requiring further improvement.
“The Fiscal Responsibility Index is not merely an assessment document or an administrative scorecard. It is an empirical, evidence-based benchmarking instrument designed to measure, score and rank Federal Ministries, Departments and Agencies according to their levels of compliance with established public financial management obligations.
“Specifically, the Index assesses institutional compliance with statutory requirements relating to public financial management practices, budgeting thresholds, procurement transparency and revenue remittance guidelines, as provided under the Fiscal Responsibility Act (FRA), 2007, and other applicable public financial management frameworks.
The fundamental objective is to provide a credible
“The fundamental objective is to provide a credible basis for measuring institutional performance, identifying compliance gaps, encouraging healthy competition among MDAs and promoting a culture of transparency, accountability and prudent utilisation of public re
Abana also expressed concern that the Commission’s poor funding was hampering its effectiveness in discharging its responsibility of monitoring MDAs. He disclosed that the Commission monitors more than 1,000 MDAs with fewer than 80 staff members.
“The Fiscal Responsibility Commission has remained committed to its functions and responsibilities and has performed creditably well with available rewers, inadequate funding, staff shortages and a lack of adequate accommodation, despite being in existence for over 16 years
Yet, through the payment of operating surpluses
“Yet, through the payment of operating surpluses and other internally generated revenue (IGR), the Commission has increased its independent revenue from just about ₦300 million in 2010 to over ₦2 trillion annually. “Government should deliberately support the Commission by strengthening its enforcement powers, amending the Fiscal Responsibility Act and increasing its funding to ensure a more effective accountability framework for Nigeria.”
The Chief Executive Officer of the Centre for Social Justice (CSJ), Eze Onyekpere, Esq., described the FRI project as part of the organisation’s efforts towards “Improving the Effectiveness of Anti-Corruption Processes and Reforms in Nigeria”, implemented with the support of the European Union, IDEAS and the Rule of Law and Anti-Corruption Project (RoLAC 2).
“The overall goal of the CSJ umbrella programme is to contribute to increased effectiveness of anti-corruption laws, policies, interventions and strategies for the entrenchment of reforms at national and subnational levels. This would lead to increased compliance with anti-corruption laws.
Anti-corruption laws and policies are not an end
“Anti-corruption laws and policies are not an end in themselves, but are expected to lead to systemic change, enhanced compliance and behavioural change in society, making it possible to increase the prevention of corruption, take corrective action in individual cases, detect and prosecute offenders, and make future breaches of the law more difficult,” he said.
The Fiscal Responsibility Index (FRI) was developed with input from civil society organisations, professional associations and government agencies. It was reviewed and revised in 2026 for the current assessment.
The index covers five sub-indices: policy-based budgeting; budget-policy linkages, comprehensiveness and transparency; budget credibility and realism; procurement, monitoring and evaluation; and accounting, recording, reporting and external audit.







1 Comment
Pingback: Senate Backs FCC, Urges Wider Probe Of MDAs Over Recruitment Irregularities - News Press NG Copy