Johnson said the footprints looked unusually natural, although he identified several inconsistencies that raised questions about their authenticity.
“If the tracks were faked, someone went to a great deal of trouble and detail. The ‘print’ marks on the foot would have to be very hard to duplicate,” Johnson wrote.
He also observed that the impressions appeared natural but questioned their consistent spacing, abrupt beginning and ending, and the absence of other expected signs of movement.
A US Border Patrol tracking expert, Joel Hardin, subsequently described the discovery as “a very clever attempt to perpetrate a hoax”, suggesting that artificial feet coated with plaster or rubber might have been used to create the impressions.
He recommended closing the investigation.
Johnson eventually concluded that the footprints discovered at two locations along Mill Creek were made by something other than a two-legged creature weighing more than 300 pounds.
1941 Montana encounter
Another document recounts an alleged encounter in 1941 at Petty Creek, Montana, involving a mysterious creature reportedly seen moving on two legs.
The account, documented by Leo T. Kinney, described how a hunting party discovered unusual footprints after an elk carcass disappeared.
Kinney and three companions had returned to retrieve the animal but found only its entrails and unusually large footprints in the snow.
The men reportedly followed the tracks for approximately half a mile before discovering evidence suggesting that something had carried the elk across a large fallen log.
They eventually abandoned the search, saying they were “not particularly anxious to catch up to whatever it was.”
The document also recounted another encounter the following year, when a hunter identified as W.W. Schmitz reportedly discovered similar footprints, detected a strong smell and heard an unusual grunting noise before leaving the area.
Strange footprints discovered near Montana sawmill
The third document contains a newspaper report dated January 13, 2003, describing hundreds of unusually large, human-like footprints discovered near the sawmill of an 87-year-old Montana resident, Jim Rohweder.
The discovery was reportedly made by an eight-year-old boy, Austin Petersen, while visiting the property with his father.
Rohweder initially believed the tracks belonged to a bear but later noticed markings resembling human toes.
The footprints reportedly measured 16.5 inches long and 8.5 inches wide, with an average distance of five feet between successive impressions.
Rohweder’s wife, Gladys, also recalled seeing a strange, hairy creature walking on two legs when they first moved to the property approximately 30 years earlier.
Despite the accounts, scientists and government officials have continued to question the existence of Bigfoot, noting that no conclusive scientific evidence has established that the creature exists.






